MINUTES AND CERTIFIED AGENDA SUNNYVALE 4A DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION REGULAR MEETING
November 1, 2007
7:00 P.M.
THE SUNNYVALE 4A
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION HELD A REGULAR MEETING ON NOVEMBER 1,2007, AT 7 P.M. IN
THE COUNCIL CHAMBERS OF THE SUNNYVALE TOWN HALL, 127 COLLINS ROAD, SUNNYVALE,
TEXAS UNDER V.T.C.A., GOVERNMENT CODE SECTION 551.041. THOSE PRESENT WERE:
PRESIDENT BILL WHITEHURST
VICE PRESIDENT JIM WADE
MEMBER DANNY ALLEN
MEMBER LAWRENCE BOYD
• CALL MEETING TO ORDER
President Whitehurst called the meeting
to order at 7:00 p.m.
·
APPROVAL OF MINUTES FROM
REGULAR MEETING OF SEPTEMBER 20, 2007.
Motion was made by Member Allan to
approve the regular minutes of September 20, 2007. Motion seconded by Member
Boyd. The motion carried 4/0.
• APPROVAL OF MONTHLY FINANCIAL REPORT
FOR SEPTEMBER 30,2007. Motion was made by member Boyd to postpone the approval
of monthly financial report for September 30, 2007 until the next meeting.
Motion was seconded by member Wade. Motion carried 4/0.
·
PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD:
PERSONS MAY ADDRESS THE SUNNYVALE 4A DEVELOPMENT BOARD ON ITEMS NOT ON THE
AGENDA. PLEASE OBSERVE THE TIME LIMIT OF THREE (3) MINUTES. CORPORATION AND ITS
MEMBERS CANNOT COMMENT OR DELLIBERATE ITEMS OF
PUBLIC COMMENT.
No public comments were made.
• REPORT BY DAVID
RAINS OF PROGRESS ON INFRASTRUCTURE IN REGARD TO THE AGREEMENT WITH THE SUNNYV
ALE 4A DEVELOPMENT CORPORAITON AND RAINS OVER TEXAS.
David Rains, 337
New Hope Rd, provided information related to the contract with the 4A Corporation.
Mr. Rains explained that one of the items was an affidavit for expenditures
related to the infrastructure for the CVS project, which was being provided to
satisfy conditions set forth in his section 5.3 of his contract with 4A. Mr.
Rains stated that the
2
final bill for the
water line was in the amount of $171,210.50, and the final amount for the water
retention was $149,855.00. He further explained that the total cost for all of
the utilities related to the CVS project was $366,761.09, and reminded the
Board that this portion included the sewer, which was not on the affidavit as
it was not part of the 4A contract. He stated that these amounts and invoices
were broken down on the distributed spreadsheet. Mr. Rains stated he believed
he was in compliance with sections 5.1, 5.2, and 5.4 of the contract and stated
he had a copy of a letter from Scott Campbell that the Town had approved and
formally accepted the utilities. He further stated that the only provision in
the contract not yet satisfied was item 5.5.
Scott Campbell, Town Manager stated
that the Town Engineer's acceptance letter was attached to the cover letter he
had provided to the Board.
Member Larry Boyd
asks David Rains how he ended up in terms of his original budget. Mr. Rains
responded that he was $76,761.09 over his original estimate, stating that the
water retention was $8,000 above what the numbers shown. He further stated that
agreement with CVS was to cap his total expenditures at 120,000; but their
final cost was approximately 128,000. He stated that there were several things
that contributed to the budget overruns to include an additional valve to allow
the CVS connection to the line and relocation of the line to avoid trees along
Beltline. Mr. Rains stated that present challenge he faced was related to the
timeline, stating the current contract expires March 1st. He stated that there
had been some delays on the actual closing of the land due to issues with
variances, and turn lanes that had to be addressed by the Town and CVS, which
postponed the closing until May 14. He stated that the rains also caused a
delay of approximately four (4) months causing the October 15 opening date to
be moved to February 14. Mr. Rains stated that the second issue regarding the
contract was related to the provision that payment would not be issued until
the Town had issued a Certificate of Occupancy, and he was requesting that the
board amend the contract, or waive this requirement to allow 4A to make their
reimbursement to him.
• INTRODUCTION
BY ASHLEY NADEAU OF MILLARD REFRIGERATED
SERVICES, INC. AND REQUEST FOR
INCENTIVES
Ashley Nadeau
presented information regarding the history of Millard Refrigeration Inc.,
stating their corporate office was in Omaha Nebraska, and their total employees
exceeded twenty two hundred. She stated that the Sunnyvale site would be the
fifth location in the state of Texas. Ms. Nadeau stated that she worked out of
the Fort Worth location, which is over 624, 000 square feet; and that another
facility is needed. She further stated that the facility that is being proposed
to open is 350,000 square feet, and 80 new jobs would be brought to Sunnyvale.
Ms. Nadeau reported a total investment of $38 million; $7 million of personal
property and $31 million of construction, stating the three phases of the
construction would be finished in five years. She added that the second largest
expense for the company would be electricity at approximately $110,000 dollars
a month, or 1.3 million dollars a year. Ms. Nadeau stated that based on the
significant size of the investment, she was asking the board to consider the
incentives requested on the
3
application, further requesting a fifty
percent tax abatement for ten years, along with the other incentives on the
application.
Member Boyd asks
if the location was a Freeport area. Ms. Nadeau stated that the company does
not own the inventory so the customers would pay the taxes, but she could not
estimate how much taxes they would pay.
4A President, Bill
Whitehurst asked if the company dealt with goods in transit, and Ms Nadeau
confirmed this was the case; further stating the customer would produce the
product, bring it to the facility, and the company would store and either ship
it out or the customer would provide transportation to ship it in or out of the
state.
Member Allan asked
the applicant what has to be accomplished in one phase before moving forward
with the other phases of the project. Ms. Nadeau stated that the space had to
be sold before continuing to the next phase, adding that there was already much
customer interest.
Pam Mundo,
explained that the goods are owned by individuals or companies other than Millard,
it cannot be determined if they are in the state for 175 or less/more, whether
or not it is subject to the freeport exemption or taxation. Walt McCool stated
that pursuant to the Tax Code, the customers would be required to render the
property and its inventory to apply for the Freeport exception to the Appraisal
District. Walt McCool asks the applicant if they provide a list of customers to
the Appraisal District, and the applicant stated that they do not. Mr. McCool
stated that the customer's goods would still be appraised as part of the
customers inventory and taxed, unless it does qualify for the freeport
exemption.
Member Boyd asked if the applicant if
she was projecting $7 million in personal property value, and $31 million in
construction, and the applicant confirmed this was correct.
Mr. Whitehurst stated the 4A Board
would review the applicant's information and contact her soon with their input
and answers.
Audience member, Mr. Paul Cash, asked
if he could address the 4A Board, and was asked by Mr. Whitehurst to approach.
Paul Cash, 347
Tripp Road, stated that in general everyone who owns a business on the 352
corridor was in favor of quality development. He stated that the main concern
of the business owners along SH 352 was the traffic in the area, stating he
does not oppose a business like Millard Refrigeration, however that he is
concerned about the eighteen wheeler traffic at and around this part of Town.
He stated that it is good that TXDOT is working on revamping the intersection,
which will hopefully alleviate some of that truck traffic. Mr. Cash also
suggested the Town adopt to a policy requiring large business to maintain a
billable business address in this Town, stating building materials, equipment,
and other items of which he may not be aware are taxable at the location where
they pay their bills, which benefits the Town. He further stated that he would
like to compliment
4
4A for assisting
businesses that are locating in our Town. He stated he felt it was important to
encourage business in this area, and that he would like to see the Town benefit
from their sales tax, and would like for the Town to start planning to address
the eighteen wheeler truck traffic.
Member Jim Wade
asked Mr. Cash to which intersection he was referring concerning the
eighteen-wheeler traffic, and Mr. Cash stated the underpass. Mr. Wade stated
that there are traffic signals now on 352 and asked if this was not adequate.
Mr. Cash stated that a two-lane road was not adequate for eighteen-wheeler
traffic.
Mr. Wade stated
that one reason for this traffic challenge was related to the Town's hesitancy
in the past to charge roadway impact fees, and not using that funding mechanism
which was available to the Town.
·
DISCUSSION/ACTION ITEMS:
1.
Tour of
Professional Bank facilities in Garland and Lakewood, Friday November 2, 20079:00 a.m
Pam Mundo stated
that Professional Bank had invited the Town Council and the Economic
Corporation to tour their Lakewood and Garland facilities as they were looking
at a potential site in Sunnyvale. 4A President, Bill Whitehurst, stated that he
toured the facility on his own time and was impressed with the CEO's attitude
at that of the bank.
Jim Wade, stated
that more than one bank was interested in locating Sunnyvale, further stating
that these banks were interested in local residents to serve as bank managers
and executives.
President Whitehurst adjourned into
executive session at 8:40 p.m. President Whitehurst reconvened the meeting at
9:25 p.m.
·
EXECUTNE SESSION AGENDA
1. PURSUANT TO
SECTION 551.087 OF THE TEXAS GOVERNMENT CODE TO DISCUSS AND DELIBERATE
COMMERCIAL OR FINANCIAL INFORMATION FROM A POTENTIAL BUSINESS PROSPECT THAT THE
BOARD IS SEEKING TO LOCATE OR EXPAND IN THE TOWN; TO DELIBERATE THE OFFER OF
FINANCIAL OR OTHER INCENTNE TO A BUSINESS PROSPECT.
2.
PURSUANT TO SECTION
551.071 OF THE TEXAS GOVERNMENT CODE TO CONSULT WITH THE ATTORNEY FOR THE
SUNNYVALE 4A DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION ON MATTERS FOR WHICH THE ATTORNEY'S DUTIES
CONFLICT WITH THE TEXAS OPEN MEETINGS ACT.
·
CONSIDER ANY ACTION AS A
RESULT OF THE EXECUTIVE SESSION
·
ADDITIONAL
DISCUSSION/ACTION ITEMS
5
A.CONSIDER
A RESOLUTION APPROVING A MEMORANDUM OUTLINING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES
THAT MAY BE OFFERED FOR COTTONWOOD PARTNERS INVESTMENTS, L.C.'S PROPOSED
HOSPITAL PROJECT AND REQUESTING TOWN COUNCIL APPROVAL OF THE MEMORANDUM.
Member Jim Wade,
made a motion to approve consideration of a resolution to encourage the
Council, with the strong support with the 4A Board, to continue their
discussions with Cottonwood Partners and the hospital project in Sunnyvale,
along the parameters of a contribution of 25% of the allowable infrastructure
in which the 4A can participate, not to exceed more than $400,000, and that we
will encourage the council to adopt a tax abatement policy along the lines
which we have approved in the past, that being a five year abatement in the
declining percentage from 100% 80, 60, 40 and 20 percent. We would encourage
the council to consider the impact fee waiver the Town has adopted for other
large projects in the past, with it not being meant to exceed $200,000 and the
board will participate with Cottonwood Partners in the preparation of a Texas
Enterprise Zone Grant application, with the cost of that being borne by 4A, and
the success of that application be applied to the incentives that we have
offered Cottonwood Partners. Member Allan seconded the motion. Motion carried
unanimously.
B.
CONSIDER APPROVAL OF AN
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WITH COTTONWOOD PARTNERS INVESTMENTS, L.C. TO
REIMBURSE UP TO $400,000 IN INFRASTRUCTURE COSTS AND REQUESTING THE TOWN
COUNCIL'S APPROVAL OF A BUDGET AMENDMENT FOR THE EXPENDITURE OF CORPORATION
FUNDS FOR THE AGREEMENT.
Motion was made by
member Jim Wade to move approval of an Economic Development Agreement with
Cottonwood Partners for their planned Hospital in Sunnyvale which would
reimburse Cottonwood Partners, upon the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy,
for an amount not to exceed $400,000 and to represent up to 25% of the
allowable infrastructure with which 4A can participate. The motion was seconded
by Member
Allan. Motion carried unanimously.
C.
CONSIDER A RESOLUTION
APPROVING A MEMORANDUM OUTLINING ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT INCENTIVES THAT MAY BE
OFFERED FOR MILLARD REFRIGERATED SERVICES, INC. PROPOSED WAREHOUSE PROJECT AND
REQUESTING TOWN COUNCIL APPROV AL OF THE MEMORANDUM.
Motion was made by
member Jim Wade to move approval of a resolution of the 4A Board to the Council
with regards to the possibility of Millard Refrigerated Services building a
warehouse project in the Town of Sunnyvale, along these parameters that we
6
would encourage
the Council to adopt a tax abatement agreement along the lines of what we have
done for other projects, that being a 5 year abatement policy in a declining
percent of 100%, 80%, 60%, 40%, and 20 percent; and that we would encourage the
council to consider any revisions that they might have regarding their impact
fee waiver policies, and that the 4A board would participate with the
assistance with the Town and Millard Refrigeration in an application of the
Texas Capital Fund for assistance in roadway improvements to Long Creek Road,
particularly to benefit their project; and also application to the Texas
Enterprise Zone for sales tax rebate. The motion was second by Member Allan.
The motion carried unanimously.
D.
CONSIDER AMENDING THE
CORPORATION'S ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT WITH RAINS OVER TEXAS, L.P. TO
PROVIDE FOR PAYMENT OF THE CORPORATION'S REIMBURSEMENT AMOUNT BEFORE ISSUANCE
OF A CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY.
A motion was made
by Member Allan to amend item 5 of the contract between the 4A Board and Rains
Over Texas to approve the disbursement of the $195,000 of the retained funds at
this time and strike the wording requiring a Certificate of Occupancy. The
motion was second by Member Wade. The motion carried 3-1, with Member Boyd
dissenting.
• PLAN DATE OF NEXT MEETING, DECEMBER
6, 2007 OR OTHER DATE
Bill Whitehurst stated that the next
meeting of the 4A Board would be December 6th•
• ADJOURN
A motion was made to adjourn the
meeting.
Mr. Whitehurst announced that a meeting
was posted for 8:30 on this night for a joint workshop with the Town Council
and 4A Board, and that this meeting was cancelled due to lack of a quorum of
the Town Council.
The undersigned presiding office
certifies that this is a true and correct record of the proceedings.
ATTEST: President,
Bill Whitehurst
______________________________ ________________________
Kathryn Dewey, Town Secretary
A TAPE RECORDING OF THIS MEETING IS ON
FILE AT TOWN HALL. THESE MINUTES ARE CONDENSED THEREFROM